
AI Receptionist vs. Answering Service vs. Hiring: Costs Compared
Short answer: A full-time receptionist costs roughly $55,000 a year in pay and benefits and covers about 40 of the week's 168 hours. A live answering service charges by the minute and usually takes messages. An AI receptionist covers every hour for a flat monthly fee and can book the job. Which one fits depends on how many calls you get, when they come in, and whether anyone needs to be at the counter.
Most local service owners reach the same point sooner or later. The phone rings more than the team can answer, and something has to change. The three usual options are to hire someone, pay an answering service, or use an AI receptionist.
Here's what each one really costs, what you get for the money, and how to decide in about 15 minutes with your own call log.
The side-by-side comparison
| In-house receptionist | Live answering service | AI receptionist | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | $38,010 median yearly pay, about $55,000 with benefits | $250 to $1,725 a month for 50 to 500 minutes (one major provider's published plans) | Flat monthly fee plus setup. Ours: $497 a month plus $1,997 setup, usage at cost. |
| Hours covered | About 40 hours a week | Depends on the provider and plan | 24/7 |
| Cost grows with | Headcount and overtime | Minutes used | Phone and text usage |
| Books appointments | Yes | Often takes a message. Some plans include scheduling. | Yes, on your calendar |
| Knows your business | Deeply, once trained | Follows a script | Trained on your services and tone |
| Sick days and turnover | Yes, your problem to cover | Not your problem | Not your problem |
| In-person work | Yes: walk-ins, paperwork, payments | No | No |
| Best for | Busy counters and complex in-person tasks | Low call volume when you want a human voice | Steady call volume, after-hours calls, booking jobs |
The real cost of hiring a receptionist
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median pay for receptionists was $38,010 a year ($18.27 an hour) in May 2025.
Pay is only part of the cost. For full-time private-industry workers, benefits made up 31.5% of total employer compensation costs in June 2026, per the BLS. If pay is the other 68.5%, a $38,010 salary works out to about $55,500 a year in total compensation.
That number still leaves out some real costs:
- Hiring and training time. Posting the job, interviewing, and teaching someone your services, prices, and calendar.
- Coverage gaps. A 40-hour week covers about 24% of the 168 hours in a week. Lunch breaks, sick days, and vacations shrink that further.
- One call at a time. When two calls come in at once, one of them waits or goes to voicemail.
- Turnover. When a front-desk employee leaves, you start the hiring and training cycle again.
A great receptionist is worth every dollar when your business needs someone in the room. For answering the phone alone, it's the most expensive option by a wide margin.
What a live answering service gets you
A live answering service puts a trained person on the phone for you, usually reading a script you approve. Many charge by the minute. As one example, Ruby, a well-known U.S. virtual receptionist service, lists plans on its pricing page from $250 a month for 50 minutes up to $1,725 a month for 500 minutes. Its 200-minute plan is $720 a month, or $3.60 a minute.
What that means in practice: a business taking 100 calls a month that last about two minutes each would land on that 200-minute plan.
The upside: callers talk to a real person, and you pay little when calls are slow.
The trade-offs:
- The agent doesn't know your business beyond the script. Questions off the script usually turn into "I'll have someone call you back."
- Many calls end as a message, not a booked job. You still make the callback, and the customer may have called someone else by then.
- Cost climbs with volume. A busy month, a storm, or a successful ad campaign means a bigger bill.
Prices and plans change, so check current pricing with any provider you consider.
What an AI receptionist gets you
An AI receptionist answers by voice, any hour, and works from what you teach it about your business. (New to the idea? Start with What is an AI receptionist?)
The upside:
- It covers all 168 hours of the week, including the evenings and weekends when many customers finally have time to call.
- It can book the appointment on your calendar during the call, instead of promising a callback.
- Cost stays predictable. A flat monthly fee doesn't jump because you had a busy week.
- It sends urgent calls to a person based on rules you set, and sends you a recap of every call.
The trade-offs:
- It can't do in-person work. No greeting walk-ins, no taking payments at the counter.
- It's only as good as its setup. It needs your services, rules, and answers, plus some tuning in the first few weeks.
- Some callers prefer a human. A good setup makes it easy to reach one when the call needs it.
For transparency, here's our own pricing: our AI Employee plan is $497 a month plus a $1,997 setup fee, with phone and text usage billed at cost. Over a first year, that's $7,961 before usage, compared with about $55,000 for a full-time hire.
The setup most owners end up with
You don't have to pick just one. A setup that works well for many owners is a hybrid:
- Your team answers during business hours when they're free, and handles anything in person.
- The AI receptionist picks up whatever your team misses: overflow, lunch hours, evenings, weekends, and holidays.
- Urgent calls go to whoever is on call, based on your rules.
Your people stop juggling the phone while helping the customer in front of them, and no caller hits voicemail.
How to decide in 15 minutes
Pull the last 30 days from your phone system or carrier and answer five questions:
- How many calls came in? Count them all.
- When did they come in? Split them into business hours and after hours (evenings, weekends, holidays).
- How many did nobody answer? Your call log will show missed and voicemail calls.
- How long is a typical call? This matters most if you're pricing a per-minute service.
- What is a new customer worth? Use the average value of a first job.
Then use this rule of thumb:
- If most of your missed calls happen while customers are standing in front of you, you may need another person at the counter.
- If you get only a handful of calls a month and want a human voice, a per-minute answering service can make sense.
- If you miss calls after hours, during jobs, or in rushes, and you want those calls booked, an AI receptionist is usually the best value.
Common questions
Is an AI receptionist cheaper than an answering service?
It depends on your volume. Per-minute services cost less when calls are rare and more as calls grow. A flat-fee AI receptionist costs the same in a slow month and a busy one, so it usually wins once call volume is steady.
Can I use an AI receptionist and keep my receptionist?
Yes, and many businesses do. The AI covers the calls your receptionist can't get to, like after-hours calls and calls that come in while they're helping someone in person.
Do answering services book appointments?
Some do, on certain plans. Many take a message and pass it to you. Ask any provider whether their agents can see your calendar and book directly.
What about after-hours emergencies?
With an AI receptionist, you define what counts as an emergency, and those calls go straight to the person on call. Everything else gets booked for the next open slot.
The bottom line
Hire a person when your business needs someone in the room. Use a per-minute answering service when calls are rare and you want a human voice. Use an AI receptionist when you want every call answered and booked around the clock for a predictable price. Many owners use a mix.
Not sure which fits your business? Book a call with Carl Saling, our founder. Bring your call log, and we'll walk through the numbers together.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Receptionists (median pay, May 2025).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 (released September 9, 2026).
- Ruby, pricing page (checked October 7, 2026).